Costco Slammed Over Popular Seasonings: "Why Are We Paying for Half a Bottle?"
Sarah Cherry
Updated on February 23, 2026
No one likes opening a bag of chips only to discover there's more air than actual munchies inside. According to Taste of Home, manufacturers purposely top-off bags with nitrogen gas to help protect and preserve your Doritos, Boom Chicka Pop, Pretzel Crisps, or whatever your favorite snack may be. But now, a Costco member has encountered a similar issue with the seasoning bottles at the popular warehouse retailer.
RELATED: Costco Shoppers Are Abandoning These Kirkland Products: "Gone Downhill."
In a video that's garnered more than 788,000 views, TikToker Jpeezy (@just_n_time_2_tok) is slamming Costco for selling name-brand seasoning bottles that are only partially full. His 30-second clip compares popular seasonings and dry rubs to Kirkland's Everything Bagel Seasoning, which is noticeably fuller than the rest.
"Why are we paying for half a bottle of seasoning?" reads the text overlay at the beginning of his video.
Jpeezy then takes followers down the herbs and spices aisle, pausing to point out seasoning bottles that aren't filled to the rim. He takes note of a bottle of Old Bay seasoning, which is commonly used on seafood, chicken, and red meat. The camera then pans to multiple containers under the brand name Kinder's before he points the finger at Spice Lab's Taco Seasoning, Dash's Salt-Free Original Seasoning Blend, and Hidden Valley Ranch Seasoning that appears to be only two-thirds full.
It isn't until Jpeezy reaches the section of Kirkland products (Costco's in-house brand) that he spots seasoning bottles filled to the cap.
"Thanks, Kirkland for filling your bottles all the way!" he says.
@just_n_time_2_tok#fyp #costco #kirkland #hiddenvalleyranch #kinders #thespicelab #oldbay #ripoff @Costco Wholesale
The video has sparked a heated debate on TikTok. While some Costco customers feel like they're being ripped off by big brands, others claim there's a logical explanation for the extra space.
"Idk why they do this," one person commented."Like the potato chips I understand why they don't fill it all the way but this one idk."
Another dubbed the controversy "shrinkflation," adding: "I remember when those bottles were much cheaper and full to the top."
Several also chimed in that spices settle overtime, which can affect how full a bottle looks. "Because powders settle differently than seeds so it might look less but as long as you're getting the weight that's labeled for sale," someone explained.
"When the spices are sitting for a while they condense because the air between the particles escapes. if you shake it up it should look more full," suggested a user.
But as many pointed out, the volume of seasoning doesn't matter as much as the weight since that's what determines the product's cost. "You're paying for the weight of the powder inside not the volume of the bottle," reads a comment.
A second person said, "YOU ARE PAYING A PRICE PER OUNCE!"
"You pay for the amount labeled on the bottle. how big the bottle is, is irrelavent," another agreed.
Emily Weaver Emily is a NYC-based freelance entertainment and lifestyle writer — though, she’ll never pass up the opportunity to talk about women’s health and sports (she thrives during the Olympics).Read moreFiled UnderFood • News • Retail • ShoppingRead This Next6 Costco Items Shoppers Say They'll Never Buy
These savvy shoppers did a price comparison so you don't have to.March 28, 20247 Ways to Get Things for Free at Costco
Experts say there are plenty of products that don't require you to break out your wallet.April 3, 2024Costco Shoppers Slam "Awful" Store-Brand Foods
They've recently shared complaints about five specific products.March 14, 20246 Kirkland Products Costco Shoppers Hate
It might be worth spending a few extra dollars elsewhere. March 13, 2024Costco Shoppers Are Abandoning Kirkland
Customers claim that many of the items they're buying are not as good as they once were.February 26, 2024The 20 Worst Things to Buy at Costco
Some of these Costco products are low quality and others just shouldn't be purchased in bulk.January 31, 2024Sam's Club Adds Vendor to Compete With Costco
The cellular partnership comes on the heels of Costco's failing smartphone services.April 15, 2024Costco Shoppers Share 6 Best Clothing Items
The retailer sells everything from stylish button-ups to durable socks.April 9, 2024Costco Is Offering Ozempic via New Program
The special plan is the result of the retailer's new partnership with a healthcare provider.April 3, 2024Costco Shoppers "Have a Bad Feeling"
"RIP $1.50 hot dog combo," one person wrote on Reddit.February 7, 2024
