Never Buy a Christmas Tree That Feels Like This, Experts Warn
Andrew Mckinney
Updated on February 23, 2026
Heading out to pick the perfect pine tree is often one of the most cherished traditions of the holiday season. But just because something looks grand and impressive on the lot doesn't mean it's a good option for your home. If you want to avoid a decorating disaster, check out these tips that can help you pick the best Christmas tree based on how it feels. Read on to see how you can easily prevent a fir failure.
RELATED: This Is the Worst Time to Buy a Christmas Tree, Experts Say.
You should never buy a Christmas tree if it feels too light when you pick it up.
Tree shopping is first and foremost a visual experience as you seek out an option that will fit perfectly in your home. But once you've found a Christmas tree with the right dimensions, you should also check to make sure the tree doesn't feel too light when you pick it up.
Due to drought and high temperatures that affected much of the U.S. this year, experts warn that any pines that don't feel heavy likely haven't absorbed enough water to make it to the holiday. "If a tree is extremely light, that's probably not going to be as healthy and strive as long as a heavier tree because that heavier tree is going to have more water in it," Justin Timm, owner of Frog Pond Farm in Wilsonville, Oregon, tells local Portland NBC affiliate KOIN.
The outer branches of the tree should feel soft and pliable without too many needles coming loose when touched.
Besides making sure it's not too light, experts suggest using your other senses to help you purchase a Christmas tree just like you would a piece of fruit or produce. You should always test to see that the bark is still smooth to the touch and that outside branches are still soft and pliable, checking for freshness by grabbing one between your thumb and forefinger and pulling towards yourself, landscape contractor Roger Cook tells This Old House. If more than a few needles come loose, you should seek out a healthier option.
Quickly shaking or moving the tree can also be an excellent way to check whether or not it's already too dried out. Cook warns that while it's normal for a healthy pine to shed needles from its interior, any tree that loses a lot of needles from the outer branches when it's put back on the ground is likely pretty dehydrated. And as always, you should make sure the tree you pick is as fragrant as possible.
Watering your tree quickly after it's cut is the best way to keep it healthy through Christmas.
Even if you've found a sufficiently healthy tree, keeping it looking its best for the weeks leading up to the holiday still takes some effort. Just like any other plant that has been clipped from its roots, experts say it's essential to make sure your spruce, pine, or fir is well hydrated as soon as you bring it home.
"Water is the absolute most important thing you can do to preserve your tree for Christmas," Jane Neubauer, co-owner of Sugar Pines Farm in Chesterland, Ohio, tells Martha Stewart, adding that that sap from the trunk rushes to the bottom of the tree when it's cut and seals it up. "When that happens, the tree isn't as able to absorb water," she says. "Add a fresh cut at the bottom right before you place it in water, and try to put up your Christmas tree the same day you bring it home."
For more home tips, sign up for our daily newsletter.
Make sure you're giving your tree enough water each day and avoid drying it out with harsh heat.
Once you have your tree decorated with plenty to drink, it's essential to keep it well-watered—especially every day for the first two weeks after it's freshly cut. "Get a tree stand with a built-in reservoir and check it regularly," Neubauer says. "People don't always realize how much water their Christmas trees will drink up. You'll need to replenish the water regularly."
Ideally, experts say you should give it one quart of water per inch of trunk diameter. And according to research, there's no reason to fret over adding aspirin, sugar, or bleach: room temperature water from the tap should do just fine.
Besides making sure your fir has plenty to drink, you can also go a long way in preserving your pine's longevity by making sure it's being showcased in the right conditions. Close any heat vents that may be near the tree that could speed up drying it out and lower the temperature in the room, Timm says. And using smaller lights can also help prevent baking the tree with high heat whenever it's lit.
RELATED: Walmart Just Made This Major Announcement for All Shoppers.
Zachary Mack Zach is a freelance writer specializing in beer, wine, food, spirits, and travel. He is based in Manhattan.Read moreFiled UnderChristmas • Holidays • News • ShoppingRead This NextThis Is the Worst Time to Buy a Christmas Tree
Doing this once-a-year purchase the wrong way can either leave you out of cash or out of options.November 27, 2021The 50 Best Holiday Gifts for Your Husband
Save yourself a trip to the mall and pick from these perfect presents instead.November 18, 20216 Holiday Decorations That Attract Spiders
If you're keeping these holiday decorations in your home, a pest infestation may not be far off. November 5, 2021The Smart Man's Guide to Spotting Counterfeit Wine
That $2,000 bottle of Bourdeaux might be worth $20. Here’s how to be sure it’s the real thing.April 13, 2017The 5 Best Light-Bodied Red Wines for Extending Your Summer
Don't let September ruin a killer party. August 25, 201717 Insanely Cool New Luxury Bicycles for Spring
Meet the bikes that cost more than a car.March 31, 2017Best Life Essentials
You deserve the best. Live life to the fullest with these ultimate essentials.October 21, 2016This Is the Safest Way to Store Meat
Don't let that filet set you up for food poisoning. February 7, 2018Here Are the 10 Wealthiest Cryptocurrency Millionaires Under 40
Including one guy who is only 24 years-old!February 7, 2018This Is the Safest Way to Clean Your Floors
Keep your floors clean and looking brand new with this easy tip. February 8, 2018
